
Tim Hortons has the habit, the independents have the personality, and Dunkin’ is getting ready to return. Add Krispy Kreme to the mix and Montreal’s doughnut scene is getting crowded. But perhaps the real battle isn’t over doughnuts at all. It’s about coffee.
Who knew doughnuts could cause so much competition? You’d think we were talking about real estate, not fried dough covered in sugar and icing.
Yet here we are. Tim Hortons has its loyal customers, Montreal’s independent shops have carved out their own following, Krispy Kreme remains in the picture, and Dunkin’ is preparing to make another run at Canada.
Everybody seems to want a piece of the business. But Montrealers can be particular about where they spend their money, especially when it comes to food. Can everybody get a bite, or will somebody be left holding an empty doughnut box?
And perhaps the bigger question is whether this is really a doughnut war or a coffee war with doughnuts on the side.
Tim Hortons Still Has the Habit
Let’s face it. Tim Hortons isn’t going anywhere just because a few independent doughnut shops have come along.
People have their routines. They know where the closest Tim’s is, what they want and how to get through the drive-through without sacrificing half their lunch break. That’s a comfortable position for any business.
But loyalty doesn’t mean everybody is happy. Spend a little time listening to longtime customers and you’ll hear familiar complaints. Some say the doughnuts aren’t as fresh as they remember. Others miss the old recipes, fillings and flavours they grew up with.
One person opening a discussion about Montreal’s best doughnut spots on Reddit didn’t mince words:
“Because the donuts from Tim Horton is a insult to donutkind.”
Well, that’s one way to put it! The grammar might need a little work, but the message certainly gets across.
Of course, one person’s opinion doesn’t speak for every Tim Hortons customer, and it doesn’t prove that the entire menu has gone downhill. Still, it gives us a glimpse of how strongly some people feel about the brand.
Here’s the interesting part: people can complain about Tim Hortons and still be back the next morning. That’s the power of habit. You might not love the doughnut, but if the coffee shop is on your way to work, convenience can win the argument.
And there’s nothing wrong with that. A quick weekday stop at Tim’s and a special weekend visit to an independent shop can happily coexist.
Montreal’s Independents Are Giving Us Something to Talk About
This is where the doughnut scene gets more interesting.
Shops like Bernie Beigne, Homers, Beigne Habitude and Léché give customers a reason to look beyond the usual coffee-and-doughnut routine.
Bernie Beigne has its traditional favourites, and its apple fritters have earned enthusiastic praise from Montreal doughnut fans. Homers takes a playful approach with colourful, oversized creations. Beigne Habitude offers brioche doughnuts, crullers and creative flavour combinations, while Léché has developed its own artisanal style.
These shops aren’t necessarily competing for the same customer or trying to make the same product. That’s part of their appeal.
Montreal food discussions offer a good illustration. In a June 2026 Reddit conversation about the city’s best beignes, one diner summed up the difference between two popular shops:
“Beigne Habitude pour des saveurs originales, Bernie Beigne pour les classiques.”
In other words, Beigne Habitude for original flavours, Bernie Beigne for the classics. It’s a pretty good description of the variety available.
The same discussion produced a less flattering assessment of Homers. One diner found its doughnuts too big, dough-heavy and dense, while naming Beigne Habitude as a personal favourite. Another simply declared:
“Bernie Beigne is the GOAT.”
For anyone unfamiliar with internet slang, that’s Greatest of All Time. Apparently, we’re not just reviewing doughnuts anymore. We’re handing out championship titles.
A few online discussions don’t represent every Montreal diner, of course. But they show that people have different expectations. Some want a familiar classic, others want unusual flavours, and some have very definite opinions about how much doughnut is too much doughnut.
The independent shops have something the big chains can’t simply manufacture: their own personalities.
Krispy Kreme Has Been Here Before
Then there’s Krispy Kreme. It isn’t a newcomer to Canada, and its history offers a reminder that a popular name doesn’t guarantee a successful expansion.
The chain grew to approximately 17 Theatre Shop locations across Canada in the early 2000s. By 2008, that number had fallen to three: Mississauga, Greenfield Park and Quebec City.
Krispy Kreme didn’t disappear, though. It later rebuilt its Canadian presence with a different approach. Its factory stores produce fresh doughnuts throughout the day, while its smaller Doughnut Cafés receive deliveries twice daily.
The company had to rethink its business model rather than simply keep opening stores. A famous name and a popular product weren’t enough to make every location work.
Krispy Kreme still has its admirers in Montreal, too. In that same June discussion, one diner even preferred it to Homers. So there’s already plenty of debate about whose doughnuts deserve the top spot.
And Now Dunkin’ Wants Another Bite
I have a bit of personal history with this one. I grew up eating Dunkin’ Donuts. It was part of the landscape, and stopping there was simply part of the routine.
But somewhere along the way, the brand seemed to become an afterthought. Many of the restaurants I remember looked as though they hadn’t been updated since the 1970s. The competition was changing, the stores seemed stuck in another era, and one by one, they started closing like dominoes.
Meanwhile, Tim Hortons was gaining ground and becoming the everyday coffee-and-doughnut stop for Canadians. Dunkin’ gradually lost its place in the market. By 2018, its last three Canadian restaurants had closed.
Now, after all these years, Dunkin’ wants another bite.
Foodtastic is behind the comeback, with Toronto expected to get the first location around late January or early February 2027. Montreal is anticipated roughly two to three weeks later, although the timing depends on construction and permits. The November 18 reporting did not identify a specific Montreal address.
But this time, there’s more to the story than doughnuts.
Coffee has always been central to the coffee-and-doughnut routine. People might make a special trip for an unusual doughnut, but a good cup of coffee can turn a visit into a daily habit. Today’s Dunkin’ has put considerable emphasis on its drinks, including iced coffee, espresso beverages and other specialty options.
That could be its opportunity in Canada. It won’t be enough to bring back a familiar name and hope customers remember the old days. The company has to give them something worth returning for.
Foodtastic CEO Peter Mammas seems to understand the challenge. In an interview with Retail Insider, he said:
“We want brands that serve great food, have good service and offer something that customers look forward to and seek out.”
He also acknowledged the importance of keeping prices affordable.
That’s where the real test begins. Dunkin’ needs the right locations, products people enjoy and a business model that makes financial sense.
I remember the old Dunkin’ Donuts. I’m curious to see what this new version brings to the table. But I have one question that matters more than any advertising campaign: Will the coffee be better?
So, Who Wins the Doughnut Wars?
I’m not convinced there has to be a winner.
Montreal may have room for all of them. Tim Hortons has its established customer base, Krispy Kreme has its recognizable doughnuts, Dunkin’ is bringing back a familiar name, and the independent shops offer something different.
For customers, that’s not a bad situation. More choice, more variety and a little competition can only make things interesting.
Of course, running a doughnut shop isn’t just about making something delicious and posting a great picture on Instagram. There’s rent, staffing, ingredients and a long list of bills to pay. A popular shop still has to make money.
Personally, I like having choices. I enjoy seeing Montreal businesses come up with their own ideas, and I don’t mind the big chains competing for our attention. Just give me something good, whether it’s a creative doughnut or a decent cup of coffee.
And here’s one last thought. When Dunkin’ opens its doors, are you going to order a double-double? Elbows up!
Wait a minute. Before we get too patriotic about Tim Hortons, remember that it belongs to Restaurant Brands International, a Canadian company with significant Brazilian investment through 3G Capital. So much for keeping the coffee business strictly Canadian!
Still, I don’t care who’s behind the counter or in the boardroom. I want my double-double. And if Dunkin’ thinks it can make a better cup of coffee, I’m willing to give it a try.
